Good Guys Wear Black | Discerning Your Vocation In The Orthodox Church

For Orthodox Christian Men Discerning A Vocation

  • Home
  • About
    • Vocation
  • Education
    • Why Seminary?
    • Pre-Seminary
    • Seminaries
    • Distance Education
  • Holy Orders
    • Major Orders
      • Bishop
      • Priest
      • Deacon
    • Minor Orders
      • Subdeacon
      • Reader
    • Military Chaplaincy
      • Become A Chaplain
      • Chaplain Candidate Programs
    • Tent Making
  • Clergy Wives
  • Media Resources
    • Website Resources
    • Parish Resources
    • Bulletin Resources
  • Contact
  • General
  • News
  • Vocation
  • Deacon
  • Priest
  • Preaching
  • Preparation
  • Tentmaking
  • Clergy Wives

Charisms and the Priesthood II: Discernment

September 19, 2011 Filed under: Leave a Comment

Share the post "Charisms and the Priesthood II: Discernment"

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

by Fr. Gregory Jensen

This is the second installment of Fr. Gregory’s series of five reflections on the Priesthood.

I argued in my last post that the priest is set aside not for liturgical service but the works of governing, teaching and counseling.  All of these are work of prudence or, to use slightly different language, fruits of the gift of discernment.  So what is discernment and what does it have to do with the priesthood?

St John Cassian describes discernment as the “eye and the lamp of the body” stresses its foundational role in the spiritual life.

“This eye sees through all the thoughts and actions of a man, examining and illuminating everything which we must do. And if it is not sound in a man, that is, if it is not fortified by good judgment and by well-founded knowledge, if it is deluded by error and by presumption, this makes for darkness in our entire body” (St John Cassian, “Conferences,” New York: Paulist Press, 1985, pp. 61-63).

The saint distinguishes four different types or modes of discernment, “material” which helps us decide if our thoughts or actions are made of “true gold or spurious.”  Second there is the ability to “reject as fake and counterfeit. . . those thoughts which have the deceptive appearance of piety.”  Third, “we must be able to detect and to abhor those which impose a viciously heretical stamp on the precious gold of Scripture.”  Fourth and finally, we must have the ability to “drive away thoughts” and courses of action that fall short of the standards of the saints.

For Cassian, discernment

“is no minor virtue, nor one which can be seized anywhere merely by human effort.”

It is rather “a very great boon of divine grace.”  The saint’s words to monastics are equally, if not more applicable to the priest.

…if a monk does not do his utmost to acquire it and if he does not have a clear knowledge of the spirits rising up against him he will surely stray like someone in a dark night amid gruesome shadows and not only will he stumble into dangerous pits and down steep slopes but he will often fall even in the level, straightforward places.

If a monk without discernment risks stumbling, how much more does a priest without discernment risk not only his own salvation but the salvation of those entrusted to his care?  To fulfill his primary function to govern, teach and counsel, the priest must cultivate the virtue of prudence.

Josef Pieper argues that just as a “work of art is true and real by its correspondence with the pattern of its prototype in the mind of the artist” so too

“the free activity of man is good by its correspondence with the pattern of prudence” (The Four Cardinal Virtues).

Unfortunately, among most clergy (in almost all traditions) the work of prudent governing is among the least valued.  And yet as Zizioulas (Eucharist, Bishop, Church,pp. 208-217) argues it is precisely for his prudence that, that is his ability to govern, teach and counsel, that a man is ordained and, in the absent of the bishop, is charged with celebrating the Eucharist and the other liturgical services of the Church.

While a solid grasp of Holy Tradition is essential for the priest, I would argue that this is secondary to the primary work of the priest.  A priest without discernment, without the ability to govern, teach and counsel wisely and prudently within the concrete circumstance of daily life, is not only of no use to the Church and the parish, he is a source of potential harm.  Yes, theology is essential to his ministry, but without discretion it is simply one more ideology competing to impose itself on the human family.

In my next post, I will return to Zizioulas’ very helpful study to fill out what it means for the priest to be a man of discernment.  After that I will, in my last post, offer some suggests for the Church’s own discernment of who does, and more importantly does not, have a vocation to the priesthood.

Until then, and as always, your comments, questions and criticisms are not only welcome they are actively sought.

In Christ,

+Fr Gregory

Source

Share the post "Charisms and the Priesthood II: Discernment"

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Related

Filed Under: Priest Tagged With: Fr. Gregory Jensen, Priesthood, St. John Cassian

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest Additions

  • Conservative Clergy vs Liberal Clergy?
  • On the Meaning and Power of a Priest’s Blessing
  • July 10-13, 2022 – Liturgical Practicum
  • History, Symbolism and Modern Use of Orarion
  • Priestly Priorities

Find it Fast

Worth A Serious Look

Preachers Institute Journey to Orthodoxy

#35 in 2018

Orthodox Blogs

Receive Updates by Email


Expertido

Start your training

www.watchfreesocceronline.com

replica watches for sale offers an modern elegant appearance and excellent performance.

https://www.replica-watches.co/ to keeping our prices low.

watchufc202.com

https://www.luxurywatch.io/ and other top famous watch brand online.

https://www.bestwatchreplica.co/ is widely copied by replica watch,

Search for it here

#35 in 2018

Orthodox Blogs


Copyright © 2023 Fr. John A. Peck · Designed by Fr. John A. Peck · Log in
 

Loading Comments...